May in New York City typically brings rapidly warming temperatures as spring advances. The 69°F threshold marks a moderate spring day—well below the seasonal average high of 75–77°F for mid-May in NYC. The fact that this market is priced at 0% YES suggests traders expect conditions significantly warmer than this threshold on May 18. This confidence likely reflects broader weather patterns: late May in the Northeast typically features warming trends driven by increasing solar angle and a more northerly jet stream. The market is essentially pricing out a cool, unseasonal day despite weather's inherent unpredictability over a 24-hour window. With only moderate liquidity ($9,968) and light volume ($672 in 24 hours), the conviction is concentrated among a small group of traders betting against any surprise cold snap.
What factors could move this market?
May weather in New York City sits at the transition between spring's unpredictability and early summer's relative warmth. The 69°F threshold is notable because it represents a genuinely cool day for mid-May—roughly 6–8 degrees below the normal May 18 average high. Historically, the NYC metro area has recorded highs below 70°F on scattered May days, but these are increasingly rare as climate patterns shift and spring progresses earlier each decade. Recent Mays have trended warmer, with late-spring high-pressure systems becoming more dominant. In 2025, May 18 saw a high of 76°F in Central Park; in 2024, it reached 74°F. A sub-70°F scenario would require either a lingering cool air mass from a late cold front, persistent cloud cover and rain, or an unusual stalling low-pressure system. The jet stream position is critical: if it remains anchored to the north (its typical May position), polar air cannot easily penetrate southward into the Northeast. Conversely, if a trough digs south, cold air and clouds could suppress temperatures. Sea-surface temperatures in the Atlantic remain relatively cool for May, but they would need to dramatically influence synoptic patterns to drive a surprise chill. The 0% market price reflects trader consensus that all ingredients point to at least average warmth—high pressure, northerly jet stream, increasing solar radiation—with the odds of all conditions aligning against a cool day viewed as negligible. Yet weather forecasts, even 24 hours out, carry inherent uncertainty, and an unusual late trough or unexpected cloud development could still upset this pricing. The market's extreme confidence is grounded in seasonal climatology but leaves little room for the genuine surprises that short-term weather can still produce.
What are traders watching for?
National Weather Service 48-hour forecast cone confidence level released May 17 evening
Upper-level jet stream position and any trough approaching Northeast on May 17–18
High-pressure system center strength and exact positioning over the region
Cloud cover development and precipitation chance: clear skies favor stronger warming
Morning low temperature reading: sub-50°F lows would make a cool high less likely
How does this market resolve?
Market resolves YES if the National Weather Service reports NYC's highest temperature on May 18 is 69°F or below; NO if the high exceeds 69°F. Official reading from Central Park, resolved May 18 at midnight UTC.
Polymarket Trade is an independent third-party interface to the Polymarket CLOB prediction market exchange on Polygon — not affiliated with Polymarket, Inc. Prediction markets aggregate trader expectations into real-time probability estimates. Every market question resolves YES or NO based on a specific event outcome; traders buy shares of the side they believe will resolve positively. Prices range 0¢ (certain no) to 100¢ (certain yes) and naturally reflect the crowd-implied probability of YES. Polymarket Trade is non-custodial — your funds never leave your wallet. Open the full interactive page linked above to place orders, see order book depth, and execute a trade.
